Thursday, 11 August 2016

Katinka Hosszu’s rise to the top: reality or a façade?

It’s been a thrilling first few days in the pool at this year’s Olympic Games, highlighted by the stunning performances of 27-year-old Hungarian Katinka Hosszu. Competing in her fourth Olympics, Hosszu has dominated the field and hauled in three gold medals, her first ever medals at the Olympics, and has set two Olympic records and one world record in the process. It’s hardly a surprise. Hosszu has been consistently brilliant since 2013, setting multiple world and championship records since. But how has someone who should be well past her best become such a revelation?

It is extremely unusual for a female swimmer to peak so late in their careers. History tells us that the best of the best often break onto the scene in their teens and peak either side of twenty. While male swimmers can often continue to perform at the highest level through to their late twenties, such a scenario is exceedingly uncommon for women. Taking a look at some of the greatest female swimmers in history, there is a common denominator: age. Dawn Fraser was 18 when she won her first gold medal in Melbourne in 1956; Shane Gould was 15 when she got three golds in 1972; Janet Evans had just turned 17 when she did the same in 1988; the list goes on and on. Even today, Katie Ledecky has transformed women’s freestyle despite only being 19. But none of the aforementioned swimmers (apart from Ledecky who is still an unknown) lasted at the top for a significant period of time. Fraser won her last gold in Rome having just turned 27, Gould retired at the age of 17, while Evans retired after failing to win any medals at the 1996 Games at the age of 25. It therefore seems hard to believe that someone who has not always been considered one of the world’s top swimmers, has suddenly become such a dominant force in her mid-twenties.

Until this week, Hosszu had failed to deliver the goods at the Olympic Games. Four years ago, Hosszu finished fourth in the 400m individual medley, eighth in the 200m individual medley, and ninth in the 200m butterfly. Realistically, such a disappointing performance should have been the end of her career. However, she persevered. The first change she made was her coach, appointing her boyfriend Shane Tusup as her trainer and motivator. Tusup has already made a splash of his own during these Olympics, with his excessive emotion and passion in the stands raising many eyebrows. According to those close to the pair, Tusup is an extremely tough trainer, who apparently is borderline inappropriate in his coaching of Hosszu. Together the pair decided to enter Hosszu in more events to lessen the pressure on her to win.

It worked. At the 2013 World Championships, Hosszu won both the 400m and 200m individual medley, and also gained a bronze in the 200m butterfly. In the following World Cup, she destroyed the rest of the field, breaking eight world records and scoring 840 points over the eight meets. The next best scored 288. In just over twelve months, Hosszu had gone from a competitor barely making finals, to a multiple world-record holder and world champion.

She has not let up her performances since. As the world watched in awe as she lowered the 400m individual medley world record by two seconds, she barely broke a sweat. This was the end product of a four-year training effort. Yet, in this day and age, one feels like such performances are too good to be true. The record she broke had been formerly held by Chinese teenager Ye Shiwen, whose rapid swim in London four years ago has since been deemed as likely to have been fuelled by performance-enhancing drugs. By not just beating, but annihilating that record, Hosszu is cast under the same shadow.

Of course, this is not the first time that such a rise has occurred. History has a way of repeating itself. In 1996 Irish swimmer Michelle Smith had a disturbingly similar rise. Having failed to medal in either of her first two Olympics, Smith romped through the field in Atlanta, winning three golds and a bronze, including two golds in the individual medley events, the same as Hosszu this time around. Smith was 26 in Atlanta and like Hosszu, had only started to ascend to the top at a late age and after a fairly mediocre career. To cap off their similarities, Smith was also coached by her husband in Atlanta. While Smith never tested positive during the Games, there remained a great deal of suspicion around her rapid rise to the top. Two years later, she was banned from swimming after she was caught manipulating a drug test. She kept her medals from Atlanta, but it is now assumed that she was probably using PEDs in the build-up to those games.


At this stage there is obviously no proof that Hosszu has taken any kind of performance enhancing drugs, nor that she is alone in doing so. However, her ascension is virtually unprecedented, especially at her age. For now, we have to assume that her hard work has paid off, but time will tell if what we saw was reality or simply a façade. 

No comments:

Post a Comment